As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Cabinet Pulls with Backplates vs Without (2026 Comparison)
If you're updating cabinets or hiding old screw holes, choosing hardware with a backplate changes both form and function. This head-to-head review compares three popular backplate-equipped options — two compact vintage knobs from Kelier and a longer, heavy-duty pull from khtumeware — so you can weigh hole coverage, surface protection and aesthetics. Products were selected from recent listings and customer feedback for build quality, ease of installation, and fit; each item is compared side-by-side for real-world use in kitchens, dressers and wardrobes.
Quick Answer
For most kitchens and furniture that need hole coverage plus a vintage look, choose Antique Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate (ASIN B0DX1QF5PS). If you prefer a long, heavy-duty pull for drawers, the khtumeware 6 Inch Champagne Bronze Cabinet Pull Backplate (ASIN B0D3C8W2ZL) is the better premium option.
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
Select 2-3 products to compare side-by-side
| Compare | Product | HandleSmith Score | Price Tier | Key Feature | Best For | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![Antique Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate, Dresser Pull Handles for Kitchen/Cupboard/Wardrobe/Cabinet, Mushroom Black](/assets/images/products/B0DX1QF5PS.jpg)
Kelier Mushroom Black Knobs
|
Budget | Antique zinc-alloy knob with backplate | Covering old holes with vintage look | Check Price | ||
![Brass Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate, Dresser Pull Handles for Kitchen/Cupboard/Wardrobe/Cabinet (Gold, 12 Pieces)](/assets/images/products/B0DKHK3KCC.jpg)
Kelier Mushroom Gold Knobs
|
Budget | Golden zinc-alloy vintage backplate knob | Budget-friendly vintage cabinet refresh | Check Price | ||
khtumeware 6" Champagne Pulls
|
Premium | 6" center-to-center heavy zinc-alloy pull | Wide drawers and heavy-duty use | Check Price |
1. Antique Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate, Dresser Pull Handles for Kitchen/Cupboard/Wardrobe/Cabinet, Mushroom Black
These mushroom-shaped knobs combine a vintage aesthetic with a built-in backplate that helps cover old screw holes and upgrade cabinet fronts. Customers praise the solid feel, ease of installation and value for money; the zinc alloy construction gives a traditional look without a premium price.
Key Specs
- Material: High-quality zinc alloy
- Size: 74 x 32 x 27 mm (approx)
- Weight: ~53 g per piece
- Screws included: 25mm and 35mm lengths (24 screws for 12 knobs)
Pros
- Covers old holes better than slim modern knobs without backplates
- Easier to install into existing single-hole cabinets than multi-hole pulls
- More affordable vintage look compared with premium metal pulls
Cons
- Single-hole design — not ideal if you need a long center-to-center pull
- Not as heavy-duty or long as cabinet pulls for wide drawers
Best For: Covering old holes with vintage look
Check Latest Price on Amazon2. Brass Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate, Dresser Pull Handles for Kitchen/Cupboard/Wardrobe/Cabinet (Gold, 12 Pieces)
The gold Kelier knobs mirror the black set in fit and function but offer a warmer brass look for traditional or transitional kitchens. They cover small cosmetic holes, install quickly with included screws, and deliver a high perceived value for the price.
Key Specs
- Material: Zinc alloy with golden finish
- Size: 74 x 32 x 27 mm (approx)
- Net weight: ~53 g per piece
- Screws included: 25mm and 35mm lengths
Pros
- Same hole-coverage advantage as the black Kelier knobs, good for hiding imperfections
- Warm finish provides a different aesthetic than the black variant
- Good value compared with more expensive brass or stainless options
Cons
- Finish may show wear faster than higher-grade plated metals
- Limited projection — not the best grab for large drawers
Best For: Budget-friendly vintage cabinet refresh
Check Latest Price on Amazon3. khtumeware 5 Pack 6 Inch(152 mm Center to Center) Champagne Bronze Cabinet Pull Backplate with Base Plate Zinc Solid Satin Brass Kitchen Cabinet Handles Drawer Pulls Cabinet Hardware
This longer champagne-bronze pull is built heavier and gives strong coverage across wider surfaces, making it better for drawers or cabinets with multiple old holes. Review feedback highlights the solid weight, attractive finish and sturdy feel, though some buyers had mixed reactions to the included screws.
Key Specs
- Material: High-quality zinc alloy with champagne bronze finish
- Overall length: 177 mm, center-to-center: 152 mm
- Width: 25 mm, projection: 40 mm
- Screws included: 25 mm and 38 mm for 0.7–1.4 inch door thickness
Pros
- Better grab and leverage than small knobs for large drawers
- Covers a wider area of surface imperfections than single-hole knobs
- More heavy-duty and substantial feeling than budget knobs
Cons
- Included screws get mixed feedback — may require replacement for some doors
- Higher price tier than the Kelier knob packs
Best For: Wide drawers and heavy-duty use
Check Latest Price on AmazonWhich One Should You Choose?
If your main goal is to cover existing holes on small doors or drawers and get the biggest visual change for the lowest cost, choose Antique Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate (ASIN B0DX1QF5PS) — they balance coverage, vintage look and simple installation. If you want the same functionality but a warmer brass tone and equivalent price, the Brass Cabinet Knobs, [12 Pack] Vintage Retro Mushroom Drawer Knobs with Backplate (ASIN B0DKHK3KCC) is the budget pick with a golden finish. If your priority is robust performance on wide drawers or heavy-use cabinetry, the khtumeware 6 Inch Champagne Bronze Cabinet Pull Backplate (ASIN B0D3C8W2ZL) is the best premium choice because it offers stronger leverage, broader surface coverage and a more substantial feel.
Best for Specific Scenarios
- Hiding small old holes on cabinet doors: Kelier Mushroom Knobs (B0DX1QF5PS or B0DKHK3KCC) because the round backplate covers single-hole blemishes quickly.
- Wide drawers or heavy daily use: khtumeware 6" Champagne Pulls (B0D3C8W2ZL) because the longer center-to-center spacing and heavier build give better leverage and durability.
- Budget kitchen refresh with vintage style: Kelier Gold Knobs (B0DKHK3KCC) because they deliver a warm brass look and easy installation at a low price tier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a backplate hide my old screw holes?
Yes — a backplate is designed to cover surrounding surface areas and can hide one or several small holes depending on its size. Choose a backplate that overlaps the blemishes by at least a few millimeters for reliable coverage.
How do I know which screw length I need?
Measure cabinet door thickness and account for any drawer front overlay. The Kelier packs include 25mm and 35mm screws for common door thicknesses; the khtumeware pulls include 25mm and 38mm screws but some installs may require longer screws — match screw length to door thickness plus the pull's threaded depth.
Are backplates better in wet areas like bathrooms?
Backplates can protect the finish around the mounting point, but corrosion resistance depends on material and plating. Choose stainless or well-plated zinc-alloy finishes and avoid thin coatings if moisture exposure is frequent.
How We Selected These Products
Our recommendations are based on data-driven analysis: we evaluated 100770+ products across 13951+ brands using a composite scoring system that weighs rating (40%), review volume (30%), price value (20%), and demand signals (10%). Every product is ranked by data, not opinions.
Last updated: July 17, 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
HandleSmith Score is our editorial ranking based on a composite analysis of product quality, value, and verified customer sentiment. Click through to Amazon for current pricing, availability, and live customer reviews.