As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Pulls with Backplates vs Without: Pros & Cons (2026 Comparison)
Thinking about whether to use pulls with backplates or plain pulls? This 2026 head-to-head compares three khtumeware cabinet pulls (3", 6" and 12" center-to-center) with a focus on three buyer priorities: covering old screw holes, the visual / style impact of a backplate, and ease of installation. I selected these because they represent the common sizes shoppers choose, share similar zinc-alloy construction and hardware, and vary in price tier and reach. Read on for quick winners, a product-by-product comparison, a detailed buying guide, and a clear recommendation for typical scenarios.
Quick Answer
For most kitchens the khtumeware 6-inch Antique Brass pull (ASIN B0D3C96ZGS) is the best balance of coverage, sturdiness and ease of install. Choose the 12-inch Champagne Bronze (B0DCVJPW5S) when you need to cover old or multiple holes; pick the 3-inch Polished Nickel (B0D93HP92R) if budget and tight spacing matter.
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
Select 2-3 products to compare side-by-side
| Compare | Product | HandleSmith Score | Price Tier | Key Feature | Best For | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6" Antique Brass Pull
|
Mid-Range | Balanced coverage and vintage look | Most cabinets needing moderate hole coverage | Check Price | ||
12" Champagne Bronze Pull
|
Premium | Longest reach — covers large hole patterns | Doors/drawers with old or multiple holes | Check Price | ||
3" Polished Nickel Pull
|
Budget | Compact, budget-friendly option | Tight spaces and budget projects | Check Price |
1. khtumeware 5 Pack 6 Inch(152 mm Center to Center Antique Brass Cabinet Pull Backplate with Base Plate Zinc Solid Vintage Kitchen Cabinet Handles Drawer Pulls Cabinet Hardware
A mid-range, weighty zinc-alloy pull that balances coverage, style and durability. Customers praise its solid feel, antique brass finish and straightforward installation; the included screws draw mixed opinions. Great for replacing standard cabinet hardware where you want a vintage look without the bulk of a long backplate.
Key Specs
- Material: Zinc alloy with antique brass finish
- Hole center: 6" (152 mm); Total length: 7" (177 mm)
- Included screws: 8-32 x 1" and 1.5" (25 mm & 38 mm)
- Cabinet thickness compatibility: 0.7"–1.4"; Projection: 1.57" (40 mm)
Pros
- Better coverage of old holes than the 3" model
- Sturdier, heavier feel than budget pulls
- Attractive antique brass finish that elevates style
Cons
- Heavier than the 3" option—may feel bulky on small drawers
- Included screws get mixed feedback; you may need to swap them
Best For: Most cabinets needing moderate hole coverage
Check Latest Price on Amazon2. khtumeware 5 Pack 12 Inch(305 mm) Center to Center Champagne Bronze Cabinet Pull Backplate with Base Plate Zinc Solid Satin Brass Kitchen Cabinet Handles Drawer Pulls Cabinet Hardware
The 12" champagne bronze pull is designed to cover wide or misaligned hole patterns and makes a strong style statement. Made from zinc alloy with a satin finish, it’s praised for its look and sturdiness, but its length and weight can be overkill on small cabinets and installation requires accurate drilling.
Key Specs
- Material: Zinc alloy with Champagne Bronze finish
- Hole center: 12" (305 mm); Total length: 13" (330 mm)
- Included screws: 8-32 x 1" and 1.5" (25 mm & 38 mm)
- Cabinet thickness compatibility: 0.7"–1.4"; Projection: 1.57" (40 mm)
Pros
- Best at covering old or multiple screw holes
- Bold, premium look compared with smaller pulls
- Sturdy zinc construction for heavy-duty use
Cons
- Too long for small drawers or tight spacing
- Heavier and trickier to align during installation
Best For: Doors/drawers with old or multiple holes
Check Latest Price on Amazon3. khtumeware 5 Pack 3 Inch(76 mm) Center to Center Polished Nickel Cabinet Pull Backplate with Base Plate Zinc Solid Kitchen Cabinet Handles Drawer Pulls Cabinet Hardware
A compact, budget-friendly zinc-alloy pull with a polished nickel finish. Buyers appreciate the value and ease of installation; it’s light and fits small drawers well, but it won’t cover larger or misaligned old holes and feels less substantial than the longer options.
Key Specs
- Material: Zinc alloy with polished nickel finish
- Hole center: 3" (76 mm); Total length: 4" (102 mm)
- Included screws: 8-32 x 1" and 1.5" (25 mm & 38 mm)
- Cabinet thickness compatibility: 0.7"–1.4"; Projection: 1.57" (40 mm)
Pros
- Best value and easiest to fit in tight spaces
- Lightweight and simple to install
- Clean polished nickel look for modern kitchens
Cons
- Does not cover old or misaligned holes
- Less substantial feel compared with larger pulls
Best For: Tight spaces and budget projects
Check Latest Price on AmazonWhich One Should You Choose?
If you want the best overall balance of coverage, sturdiness and style, buy the khtumeware 6" Antique Brass pull (ASIN B0D3C96ZGS). It hides common small misalignments better than the 3" without the installation headaches of a 12" piece. If your project has old or widely spaced holes to conceal, choose the khtumeware 12" Champagne Bronze (ASIN B0DCVJPW5S) — it offers the most coverage and a premium look. If budget and tight spacing are your priorities, the khtumeware 3" Polished Nickel (ASIN B0D93HP92R) is the practical pick.
Best for Specific Scenarios
- Refinishing older cabinets: khtumeware 12" (B0DCVJPW5S) because its long center-to-center covers multiple old holes and hides patching.
- Standard kitchen update: khtumeware 6" (B0D3C96ZGS) because it balances look, feel and installs easily on most doors and drawers.
- Tight spaces or budget remodel: khtumeware 3" (B0D93HP92R) because it’s compact, affordable and quick to install.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a backplate pull cover old screw holes?
Yes—longer center-to-center pulls cover more old holes. The 12" (305 mm center) model covers the widest patterns; the 6" covers moderate misalignments; the 3" will only cover very small gaps or single holes.
Are the included screws good enough?
Included screws work for many installations, but customers commonly report swapping them for the right length or sturdier fasteners, especially on thicker or thinner cabinet faces. Measure cabinet thickness and have alternatives on hand.
Which finish is easiest to keep looking new?
Finishes on zinc alloy pulls (antique brass, champagne bronze, polished nickel) clean easily with a soft cloth and mild soap. For wet areas, opt for stainless or corrosion-resistant coatings; none of these are marketed as specialized waterproof hardware.
How We Selected These Products
Our recommendations are based on data-driven analysis: we evaluated 100770+ products across 13951+ brands using a composite scoring system that weighs rating (40%), review volume (30%), price value (20%), and demand signals (10%). Every product is ranked by data, not opinions.
Last updated: June 28, 2026
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
HandleSmith Score is our editorial ranking based on a composite analysis of product quality, value, and verified customer sentiment. Click through to Amazon for current pricing, availability, and live customer reviews.